National Security
12:27 pm
Mon May 14, 2012

Military Looks To Redefine PTSD, Without Stigma

Originally published on Mon May 14, 2012 2:49 pm

The military and the Department of Veterans Affairs say they want more veterans and service members to get appropriate treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD.

That's why they're tweaking the way they define and treat PTSD. But if this approach works, it could add to the backlog of PTSD cases.

For years, the standard definition for post-traumatic stress disorder had a key feature that didn't fit for the military. It said that the standard victim responds to the trauma he or she has experienced with "helplessness and fear."

Elspeth Cameron Ritchie, a former psychiatrist with the Army, says that may be true for civilians. But, she says, military people are trained to do just the opposite.

"When the IED, the improvised explosive device, goes off, they pick up their weapon, lay down suppressing fire, drag their buddies into safety and go on about doing what they're trained to do," she says.

Encouraging Treatment

New Army guidance says, don't expect military men and woman to respond to trauma this way. Even if they are "soldiering through" the pain, they may still need treatment for post-traumatic stress.

This is just one of a number of adjustments the military and the VA are making — they're essentially giving the benefit of the doubt to people who show signs of stress.

Ritchie says opening up the definition will allow more service members to get treatment.

"So that you bring in people who are doing exactly what they've been trained to do and make sure they get the care and treatment they need," she says.

The new Army guidance clarifies other pieces of the PTSD diagnosis that might mean one thing for civilians, and something completely different in the military.

Take "malingering," or faking illness. Dr. Charles Hoge of the Army Surgeon General's office says that for a service member, that word could lead to denial of benefits, or even punishment.

"These are legitimate diagnoses, but they do have different implications and ramifications in the military because of the administrative processes that can happen around those types of diagnoses," he says.

Removing The Stigma

Through these changes, the Army and the Department of Veterans Affairs are hoping to peel away the stigma still associated with this condition. In doing so, there's also a good chance that more people will seek treatment. And that could add to the growing number of PTSD cases in the military.

The VA recently announced it will hire more therapists, doctors and support staff, in an effort to shorten the long wait times for an appointment in some places.

Dr. Mary Schohn, director of mental health operations at the VA, says rural areas are a particular problem. So the agency is sponsoring special training internships.

"So some of the last internship positions that have opened up have been in rural areas because we know that people who tend to train in areas are more likely to stay there," she says.

But some say no amount of hiring can keep pace with the growing number of cases.

"There aren't enough therapists in our country to deal with the number of individuals coming back with traumatic stress symptoms," says Elaine Miller-Karas, director of the Trauma Resource Institute, based on the West Coast.

Alternative Approaches

Miller-Karas says that simply rounding up enough psychiatrists and therapists for all these men and women isn't enough. Alternative approaches are essential, she says — relaxation techniques, exercise and other ways to help people who don't want to be labeled with a disorder.

"Many of our young men and women coming back don't want to go to a mental health therapist. But they will go someplace and learn skills for wellness to increase their resiliency," she says. Miller-Karas is focusing on training community health workers and family members in coping with post-traumatic stress.

Hoge of the Army's Surgeon General's office says says clinicians usually turn to traditional talk therapy and medication first because they've been tested. "But if they don't work, clinicians will very often move to treatments that don't have as strong evidence," he says.

Proven or not, alternative therapies may be needed to manage the workload created by all the troops seeking help.

Copyright 2012 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED, from NPR News. I'm Melissa Block.

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

And I'm Robert Siegel.

The military and the Department of Veterans Affairs want more troops and vets to get the right treatment for Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. That's why they're tweaking the way they define PTSD. But the effort to encourage military men and women to seek help could create another challenge.

As NPR's Larry Abramson reports, it could add to the backlog of PTSD cases.

LARRY ABRAMSON, BYLINE: For years, the standard definition for Post Traumatic Stress Disorder had a key feature that didn't fit for the military. It said that the standard victim responds to the trauma they've experienced with helplessness and fear.

Elspeth Cameron Ritchie, a former psychiatrist with the Army, says that may be true for civilians. But she says military people are trained to do just the opposite.

ELSPETH CAMERON RITCHIE: When the IED, the improvised explosive device, goes off, they pick up their weapon, lay down suppressing fire, drag their buddies into safety and go on about doing what they're trained to do.

ABRAMSON: New Army guidance says don't expect military men and woman to respond to trauma this way. But even if they are soldiering through the pain, they may still need treatment for post traumatic stress. This is just one of a number of adjustments the military and the VA are making. They're essentially giving the benefit of the doubt to people who show signs of stress.

Elspeth Ritchie says this is great. Opening up the definition will allow more servicemen and woman to get treatment.

RITCHIE: So that you bring in people who are doing exactly what they've been trained to do and make sure that they get the care and treatment they need.

ABRAMSON: The new Army guidance clarifies other pieces of the PTSD diagnosis that might mean one thing for a civilian and something completely different in the military. Take malingering, faking illness: Dr. Charles Hoge of the Army Surgeon General's office says for a service member, that word could lead to denial of benefit or even punishment.

DR. CHARLES HOGE: These are legitimate diagnoses, but they do have different implications and ramifications in the military because of the administrative processes that can happen around those types of diagnoses.

ABRAMSON: Through these changes, the Army and the Department of Veterans Affairs are hoping to peel away the stigma still associated with this condition. In doing so, there's also a good chance that more people will seek treatment. And that could add to the growing number of PTSD cases in the military. The VA recently announced it will hire more therapists, doctors and support staff, in order to shorten the long wait times for an appointment in some places.

Dr. Mary Schohn, director of mental health operations at the VA, says rural areas are a particular problem. So the agency is sponsoring special training internships.

DR. MARY SCHOHN: So some of the last internship positions that have opened up have actually been in rural areas, because we know that people who tend to train in areas are more likely to stay there.

ABRAMSON: But some say no amount of hiring can keep pace with the growing number of cases.

ELAINE MILLER-KARAS: There aren't enough therapists in our country to deal with the number of individuals coming back with traumatic stress symptoms.

ABRAMSON: Elaine Miller-Karas is director of the Trauma Resource Institute, based on the West Coast. She says simply rounding up enough psychiatrists and therapists for all these men and women isn't enough. She says alternative approaches are essential: relaxation techniques, exercise and other ways to help people who don't want to be labeled with a disorder.

MILLER-KARAS: Many of our young men and women coming back, they don't want to go to a mental health therapist. But they'll go someplace and learn skills for wellness to increase their resiliency.

ABRAMSON: Miller-Karas is focusing on training community health workers and family members in coping with post traumatic stress.

Dr. Charles Hoge of the Army's Surgeon General's office, says clinicians usually turn first to traditional talk therapy and medication because they've been tested.

HOGE: But if they don't work, clinicians will very often move to treatments that don't have as strong evidence.

ABRAMSON: Proven or not, alternative therapies may be needed to manage the workload created by all the troops seeking help.

Larry Abramson, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.